Skip to main content

Table 5 Association of satisfaction score of the health care providers to the area of practice

From: Attitude and satisfaction of health care providers towards clinical pharmacy services in Ethiopia: A post-deployment survey

 

Ward

Satisfied (n, %)

Dissatisfied (n, %)

AOR (95 % CI)

Current Clinical Pharmacists Activities in your setting

Internal medicine

160 (70.0)

70 (30.0)

1.00

 

Pediatrics

67 (61.0)

43 (39.0)

0.70 [0.43–1.14]

 

Surgery

20 (53.0)

18 (47.0)

0.45 [0.22–0.93]*

 

Emergency

16 (61.5)

10 (38.5)

0.67 [0.28–1.57]

 

Outpatient department

35 (55.5)

28 (44.5)

0.55 [0.30–1.00]

 

Gynecology/Obstetrics

15 (42.0)

21 (58.0)

0.30 [0.14–0.64]*

 

Psychiatry

10 (59.0)

7 (42.0)

0.57 [0.20–1.60]

 

Others

16 (55.0)

13 (45.0)

0.51 [0.22–1.17]

 

Total

339 (62.0)

210 (38.0)

 

Clinical pharmacists actively participate in ward rounds with the health care team

Internal medicine

170 (74.0)

60 (26.0)

1.00

 

Pediatrics

66 (60.0)

44 (40.0)

0.551 [0.33–0.90]*

 

Surgery

21(55.0)

17 (45.0)

0.39 [0.18–0.80]*

 

Emergency

14 (54.0)

12 (46.0)

0.38 [0.16–0.89]*

 

Outpatient department

34 (54.0)

29 (46.0)

0.37 [0.20–0.67]*

 

Gynecology/Obstetrics

19 (53.0)

17 (47.0)

0.37 [0.18–0.79]*

 

Psychiatry

14 (82.0)

3 (18.0)

1.51 [0.41–5.51]

 

Others

15 (52.0)

14 (48.0)

0.36 [0.15–0.88]*

 

Total

353 (64.0)

196 (36.0)

 

Clinical pharmacists provide timely information on drug availability

Internal medicine

171 (74.0)

59 (26.0)

1.00

 

Pediatrics

81 (74.0)

29 (26.0)

0.931 [0.55–1.57]

 

Surgery

28 (74.0)

10 (26.0)

0.84 [0.38–1.88]

 

Emergency

21 (80.8)

5 (19.0)

1.38 [0.49–3.87]

 

Outpatient department

50 (79.0)

13 (21.0)

1.12 [0.56–2.25]

 

Gynecology/Obstetrics

22 (61.0)

14 (39.0)

0.50 [0.23–1.05]

 

Psychiatry

13 (76.5)

4 (23.5)

1.04 [0.32–3.37]

 

Others

16 (55.0)

13 (45.0)

0.36 [0.15–0.82]*

 

Total

402 (73.0)

147 (27.0)

 

Clinical pharmacists provide information on the appropriate route of administration

Internal medicine

176 (76.5)

54 (23.5)

1.00

 

Pediatrics

78 (71.0)

32 (30.0)

0.70 [0.41–1.18]

 

Surgery

26 (68.0)

12 (22.0)

0.53 [0.24–1.16]

 

Emergency

24 (92.0)

2 (8.0)

3.52 [0.80–15.49]

 

Outpatient department

50 (80.0)

13 (21.0)

1.10 [0.53–2.25]

 

Gynecology/Obstetrics

18 (50.0)

18 (50)

0.26 [0.12–0.56]*

 

Psychiatry

10 (59.0)

7 (41.0)

0.38 [0.137–1.09]

 

Others

22 (76.0)

7 (24.0)

0.74 [0.29–1.89]

 

Total

404 (73.5)

145 (26.0)

 

Clinical pharmacists counsel patients during discharge***

Internal medicine

135 (59.0)

95 (41.0)

1.00

 

Pediatrics

54 (49.0)

56 (51.0)

0.66 [0.41–1.06]

 

Surgery

22 (58.0)

16 (42.0)

0.733 [0.35–1.52]

 

Emergency

15 (58.0)

11 (42.0)

0.901 [0.39–2.08]

 

Outpatient department

29 (46.0)

34 (54.0)

0.500 [0.27–0.91]*

 

Gynecology/Obstetrics

16 (44.0)

20 (56.0)

0.463 [0.22–0.97]*

 

Psychiatry

13 (76.5)

4 (23.5)

2.094 [0.65–6.72]

 

Others

16 (55.0)

13 (45.0)

0.746 [0.32–1.70]

 

Total

300 (55.0)

249 (45.0)

 

Clinical pharmacists participate in dose calculation for patients

Internal medicine

161 (70.0)

69 (30.0)

1.00

Pediatrics

77 (70.0)

33 (30.0)

1.01 [0.60–1.69]

Surgery

30 (79.0)

8 (21.0)

1.28 [0.54–3.04]

Emergency

16 (61.5)

10 (38.5)

0.59 [0.25–1.41]

Outpatient department

48 (76.0)

15 (24.0)

1.22 [0.62–2.43]

Gynecology/Obstetrics

17 (47.0)

19 (53.0)

0.32 [0.15–0.68]*

Psychiatry

13 (76.5)

4 (23.5)

1.16 [0.35–3.79]

Others

24 (83.0)

5 (18.0)

1.48 [0.52–4.16]

Total

386 (70.0)

163 (30.0)

 

Clinical pharmacist identify and report adverse drug reactions

Internal medicine

159 (69.0)

71 (31.0)

1.00

Pediatrics

71 (64.5)

39 (35.5)

0.80 [0.48–1.32]

Surgery

22 (58.0)

16 (42.0)

0.44 [0.20–0.94]*

Emergency

19 (73.0)

7 (27.0)

1.09 [0.43–2.76]

Outpatient department

43 (68.0)

20 (32.0)

0.87 [0.45–1.66]

Gynecology/Obstetrics

21 (58.0)

15 (42.0)

0.53 [0.24–1.14]

Psychiatry

12 (71.0)

5 (29.0)

0.89 [0.29–2.78]

Others

21 (72.0)

8 (28.0)

0.83 [0.33–2.04]

Total

368 (67.0)

181(33.0)

 

Overall satisfaction towards Clinical pharmacy services in your setting***

Internal medicine

171 (75.0)

57 (25.0)

1.00

Pediatrics

74 (68.0)

35 (32.0)

0.66 [0.39–1.11]

Surgery

25 (68.0)

12 (32.0)

0.56 [0.25–1.24]

Emergency

21 (81.0)

5 (19.0)

1.26 [0.44–3.57]

Outpatient department

44 (70.0)

19 (30.0)

0.72 [0.37–1.40]

Gynecology/Obstetrics

16 (47.0)

18 (53.0)

0.24 [0.11–0.54]*

Psychiatry

12 (71.0)

5 (29.0)

0.66 [0.21–2.02]

Others

22 (76.0)

7 (24.0)

0.78 [0.30–1.99]

Total

385 (71.0)

158 (29.0)

 

Clinical pharmacists provide information on alternative drug regimens

Internal medicine

100 (80.0)

25 (20.0)

1.00

Pediatrics

41 (73.0)

15 (29.0)

0.641 [0.29–1.38]

Surgery

21 (87.5)

3 (12.5)

1.18 [0.31–4.48]

Emergency

5 (71.0)

2 (29.0)

0.50 [0.08–2.90]

Outpatient department

31 (77.5)

9 (22.5)

0.63 [0.24–1.62]

Gynecology/Obstetrics

18 (64.0)

10 (36.0)

0.32 [0.12–0.83]*

Psychiatry

4 (67.0)

2 (33.0)

0.33 [0.05–2.10]

Others

10 (91.0)

1 (9.0)

1.60 [0.19–14.62]

Total

230 (77.0)

67 (23.0)

 

Clinical pharmacists advise about cost effective medication alternatives

Internal medicine

99 (80.0)

25 (20.0)

1.00

Pediatrics

39 (70.0)

17 (30.0)

0.53 [0.25–1.14]

Surgery

17 (71.0)

7 (29.0)

0.36 [0.12–1.07]

Emergency

5 (71.0)

2 (29.0)

0.53 [0.09–3.08]

Outpatient department

30 (75.0)

10 (25.0)

0.46 [0.18–1.14]

Gynecology/Obstetrics

18 (64.0)

10 (36.0)

0.32 [0.12–0.82]*

Psychiatry

4 (67.0)

2 (33.0)

0.31 [0.48–2.05]

Others

8 (73.0)

3 (27.0)

0.35 [0.07–1.60]

Total

220 (74.0)

76 (26.0)

 

Clinical pharmacists participate in dose adjustment for pediatrics and patients with impaired renal and/or liver function***

Internal medicine

95 (77.0

29 (23.0)

1.00

Pediatrics

38 (68.0)

18 (32.0)

0.62 [0.30–1.30]

Surgery

15 (62.5)

9 (37.5)

0.27 [0.09–0.79]*

Emergency

5 (71.0)

2 (29.0)

0.70 [0.12–4.08]

Outpatient department

28 (70.0)

12 (30.0)

0.43 [0.18–1.04]

Gynecology/Obstetrics

15 (54.0)

13 (46.0)

0.23 [0.09–0.60]*

Psychiatry

3 (50.0)

3 (50.0)

0.16 [0.02–1.05]

Others

9 (82.0)

2 (18.0)

0.68 [0.12–3.73]

Total

208 (70.0)

88 (30.0)

 

Clinical pharmacists actively participate in bedside discussions to assist clinicians on therapeutic care plans and drug selection***

Internal medicine

88 (71.5)

35 (28.5)

1.00

Pediatrics

28 (50.0)

28 (50.0)

0.39 [0.20–0.78]*

Surgery

16 (67.0)

8 (33.0)

0.58 [0.21–1.58]

Emergency

3 (43.0)

4 (57.0)

0.28 [0.05–1.40]

Outpatient department

25 (62.5)

15 (37.5)

0.47 [0.21–1.06]

Gynecology/Obstetrics

16 (42.0)

12 (58.0)

0.41 [0.16–0.99]*

Psychiatry

3 (50.0)

3 (50.0)

0.26 [0.04–1.55]

Others

7 (64.0)

4 (36.0)

0.38 [0.09–1.49]

Total

186 (63.0)

109 (37.0)

 

Clinical pharmacists participate in preventing, detecting and resolving any drug interactions

Internal medicine

173 (75.0)

57 (25.0)

1.00

Pediatrics

77 (70.0)

33 (30.0)

0.74 [0.44–1.25]

Surgery

26 (68.0)

12 (32.0)

0.56 [0.26–1.23]

Emergency

20 (77.0)

6 (23.0)

0.97 [0.36–2.57]

Outpatient Department

45 (71.0)

18 (29.0)

0.71 [0.36–1.36]

Gynecology/Obstetrics

21 (58.0)

15 (42.0)

0.40 [0.19–0.87]*

Psychiatry

13 (76.0)

4 (24.0)

0.89 [0.27–2.90]

Others

20 (69.0)

9 (31.0)

0.53 [0.22–1.29]

Total

395(72.0)

154(28.0)

 

Clinical pharmacists advise nurses on storage/handling of drugs

Internal medicine

69 (62.0)

43 (38.0)

1.00

Pediatrics

36 (64.0)

20 (36.0)

1.02 [0.51–2.03]

Surgery

8 (57.0)

6 (43.0)

0.76 [0.24–2.39]

Emergency

12 (68.0)

6 (33.0)

1.24 [0.43–3.60]

Outpatient department

20 (83.0)

4 (17.0)

4.11 [1.14–14.76]*

Gynecology/Obstetrics

10 (83.0)

2 (17.0)

2.07 [0.40–10.69]

Psychiatry

5 (45.5)

6 (54.5)

0.55 [0.15–1.93]

Others

12 (66.7)

6 (33.3)

1.15 [0.39–3.38]

Total

172 (65.0)

93 (35.0)

 
  1. Data was analyzed by multivariable logistic regression; * p < 0.05; *** Indicates the presence of non–response by respondents; The following other 16 items were found to be not significant. Clinical pharmacists are involved in drug preparation (reconstitution, reformulation, dilution); Clinical pharmacists assist nurses in managing drug infusion rates; Clinical pharmacists advise nurses on the compatibility of IV drug administration/admixture ; Clinical pharmacists document their services in patient care; Clinical pharmacists counsel patients regarding the safe and appropriate use of medications; Clinical pharmacists are involved in side effect prevention and management